Case Details
For Applicant(s):
clarification in court by Ms Chan, Solicitor acting; Ms Angel Chan, Huen & Partners, solicitor
Listing:
CHAN KING YIP MARK v. THE INCORPORATED OWNERS OF GREENVILLE GARDENS OF SHIU FAI TERRACE
CHAN KING YIP MARK v. THE INCORPORATED OWNERS OF GREENVILLE GARDENS OF SHIU FAI TERRACE
[2026] HKLdT 57 · LDBM 83/2026
LDBM 83/2026
[2026] HKLdT 57
IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
BUILDING MANAGEMENT APPLICATION NO 83 OF 2026
___________________
BETWEEN
|CHAN KING YIP MARK |Applicant |
|and | |
|THE INCORPORATED OWNERS OF GREENVILLE GARDENS OF SHIU|Respondent |
|FAI TERRACE | |
___________________
|Before: |Her Honour Judge Michelle Lam |
| |Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal |
|Dates of Trial: |7 October 2026 |
|Date of Judgment: |8 October 2026 |
|J U D G M E N T |
INTRODUCTION
1. This is an application made by a registered owner of an
estate for dissolution of the management committee of the
Respondent and appointment of an administrator pursuant to
Section 31 of the Building Management Ordinance, Cap. 344
(“Ordinance”).
BACKGROUND
2. By the Deed of Gift dated 21 June 2013, the Applicant became
the registered owner of a residential unit of the Greenville
Gardens of Shiu Fai Terrace, Wanchai, Hong Kong (“Estate”).
He has been living in the Estate for more than 10 years. The
Estate is a private estate consists of 4 blocks of buildings,
providing a total of around 317 flats. There are also car
parking spaces within the Estate.
3. The Respondent, which was incorporated on 25 January 1983, is
duty-bound to manage the Estate in full compliance with the
Ordinance and the Deed of Mutual Covenant dated 24 February
1975 (and registered in the Land Registry by Memorial No.
UB1146817) (“DMC”).
4. Under Section 18 of the Ordinance, the Respondent is required
to maintain the common parts and the property of the
corporation in a state of good and serviceable repair and
clean condition; carry out such work as may be ordered or
required in respect of the common parts by any public officer
or public body in exercise of the powers conferred by any
Ordinance; and do all things reasonably necessary for the
enforcement of the obligations contained in the deed of
mutual covenant (if any) for the control, management and
administration of the building.
5. Under the Ordinance, the powers and duties of the Respondent
are exercised and performed on its behalf by a management
committee. The number of members of the management committee
is governed by Section 1(1) and (2) of Schedule 2 of the
Ordinance, which provides that:-
“(1) The number of members of a management committee shall be
as follows—
a) where the building contains not more than 50 flats, the
number of members shall be not less than 3;
b) where the building contains more than 50 flats but not
more than 100 flats, the number of members shall be not
less than 7;
c) where the building contains more than 100 flats, the
number of members shall be not less than 9.
(2) Subject to subparagraph (1), the number of members of a
management committee shall be decided by a resolution of the
owners under paragraph 2(1)(a).”
6. Since the Estate has more than 100 flats, the minimum number of any
management committee of the Respondent shall not be less than 9.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
7. By filing of the Notice of Application on 29 May 2026 and further
clarification in court by Ms Chan, Solicitor acting for the Applicant, the
Applicant now seeks an order under Section 31 of the Ordinance that the
incumbent management committee be dissolved and Guardian Property
Management Limited (“Guardian”) be appointed as an administrator of the
Estate without remuneration solely for the purpose of convening and
conducting a general meeting of owners for election of new management
committee members for the Respondent (“Specified Duty”) with no order as to
costs of the present proceedings.
8. For an application under section 31 of the Ordinance, the general
rule is that given the nature of the relief sought under section 31 of the
Ordinance, all the incumbent members of the management committee and the
incorporated owners should be made a party to the proceedings because they
would obviously be affected by the relief sought in the application. The
absence of a proper party is not a mere procedural irregularity but a
matter of substantive rights : Leung Ho Sing and Others v Shum Yiu Tung and
Others CACV108/2006, Unreported, 21 July 2006 §§9-12.
9. In the present case, it is the Applicant’s pleaded case that all the
management committee members had already resigned in the end of June 2025
and the management committee has since been left in a vacuum. I therefore,
at the call-over hearing on 24 August 2026, directed the Applicant to file
witness statement together with the relevant documents for proof of the
election and resignation of all management committee members, the identity
and status of the Applicant and the Respondent as well as the curriculum
vitae and consent of his nominated administrator. In particular, the
relevant registration documents lodged with the Land Registry should be
exhibited.
10. Given no member of the management committee would be joined as a
party to this action and there would be no one acting for the Respondent, I
also gave directions on additional requirement for service of documents in
this action.
11. According to the two affirmations filed for the Applicant
respectively on 4 June 2026 and 24 September 2026, the Applicant has
effected service of the Notice of Application, Court Order dated 24 August
2026, witness statement, opening submission on the Respondent by leaving at
the registered office of the Respondent as well as by displaying the same
at the main entrance and the notice board of each of the four blocks of the
Estate to ensure the present application was made known to all owners of
the Estate.
12. So far, there has been no application or Notice of Opposition filed
against the present application. Nor has there been any person appeared in
the hearing to oppose the present application. The Applicant is the sole
witness in this action. He filed his witness statement on 11 September
2026 and gave evidence in court.
LEGAL PRINCIPLES
13. Under section 31 of the Ordinance, the Lands Tribunal is empowered
to grant an order to dissolve the management committee and appoint
an administrator. Section 31 provides: -
“(1) The tribunal may, upon application made to it by—
(a) an owner;
(b) a registered mortgagee (if any);
(c) an administrator; or
(d) the Authority or an authorized officer,
dissolve the management committee and appoint an
administrator, or remove and replace an administrator, as the
case may be.
(2) The tribunal may direct that an administrator appointed
under subsection (1) shall hold office for an indefinite
period or for a fixed period on such terms and conditions as
to remuneration or otherwise as it thinks fit, and the
remuneration and expenses of the administrator shall be
deemed to be part of the expenses of management of the
building under this Ordinance.”
14. In determining an application under section 31 of the Ordinance, the
proper approach to be adopted was summarized in §18 of Woo Man Fong v IO of
Broadview Court (Shum Wan Road) and others [2021] HKCA 1598. In that case,
the Court of Appeal approved the approach adopted by the Lands Tribunal
that the applicant is to produce sufficient evidence to show that:-
1) the management committee were unable to perform their duties
under the deed of mutual covenant and the Ordinance; and
2) the nominated administrator is an appropriate administrator to
be appointed.
DISSOLUTION AND APPOINTMENT
15. It is unchallenged evidence that by a resolution of the Extraordinary
General Meeting of the Estate on 17 December 2024, 9 management
committee members and 1 non-member secretary were elected to form the
current management committee of the Respondent[1]. However, all of
them tendered their resignations on 27 June 2025 and since then, no
one has acted as the members, chairman, secretary or treasurer of the
management committee or for and on behalf of the Respondent to manage
the Estate or discharge the duties under the DMC and the Ordinance.
Their resignations were recorded by the Notice of Change of
Particulars dated 27 June 2025, which was filed with the Land Registry
on 22 July 2025 pursuant to section 12(3) of the Ordinance.
16. In the circumstances, the Estate has been in a state of anarchy after
27 June 2025. Absent an operative management committee, the
Respondent cannot function and the management of the Estate is at
risk. Further, the Applicant gave evidence that the Respondent had
been prosecuted by a company in an arbitration case since early 2025
and the case was on-going. It is also said that the bank account of
the Respondent is now frozen.
17. Thus considered, it is necessary to convene a general meeting of
owners for election of new members to form the management committee of
the Respondent in order to manage the Estate and perform the duties
under the Ordinance and the DMC without delay.
18. In this regard, the Applicant has produced solid evidence for proof
that there are indeed 10 eligible owners who have expressed their
willingness and readiness to run for the members of the management
committee. Amongst, a letter jointly signed by 9 owners of the said
10 owners[2] (with their names stated therein and the land search
record for proof of their ownership of the undivided shares of the
Estate exhibited thereto) is produced to prove the said owners’
intentions to stand in the contemplated election.
19. In the circumstances, given all members of the management committee
have resigned, no general meeting of owners can be convened without
the intervention of the Tribunal as a meeting of the corporation can
only be convened by the management committee (pursuant to section 1(1)
of Schedule 3 of the Ordinance) or by the Chairman of the management
committee at the written request of not less than 5% of the owners
(pursuant to section 1(2) of Schedule 3 of the Ordinance).
20. Thus considered, I am convinced that all members of the incumbent
management committee have resigned and no one has been able to perform
the duties imposed on the management committee members and the
Respondent under the DMC and the Ordinance. Accordingly, I accept the
Applicant’s application for appointment of an administrator solely for
the Specified Duty under section 31 of the Ordinance is necessary and
proper.
NOMINATED ADMINISTRATOR
21. For the following reasons, I am persuaded that Guardian, as nominated
by the Applicant, is a fit and proper legal person to be appointed as
administrator for the present purpose.
22. First, Guardian is the incumbent property management company of the
Estate. It undoubtedly has actual knowledge and solid experience of
managing the Estate as well as dealing with the owners of the Estate.
Actually, it has assisted the former management committees of the
Respondent to convene and hold general meetings no later than December
2024. Confirmation was given by the Applicant and Ms Chan, after
consulting the representative of Guardian in Court, that its service
agreement with the Respondent is still valid and will continue no less
than the next three months.
23. Second, according to the curriculum vitae of Guardian, which is
unchallenged evidence in this case, Guardian is a property management
company under the group of Savills Guardian in Hong Kong. It was
incorporated on 27 September 1977. Since its incorporation, Guardian
has been providing property management services to a number of estates
in Hong Kong with a considerable number of employees employed for such
services. It apparently has solid experience and resources in
property management and to perform and discharge the Specified Duty.
24. Third, the scope of the appointment is limited and well-defined to the
Specified Duty solely.
25. Fourth, Guardian has, by way of a consent letter dated 14 May 2026
(“Consent Letter”), confirmed their willingness, readiness and
commitment to act as the administrator for the Specific Duty without
remuneration. It confined its scope of service and duties under the
appointment to the Specified Duty and made itself clear that once the
management committee members are elected, its role will conclude and
its duty will be fully discharged upon the conclusion of the relevant
meeting.
26. Fifth, by the Consent Letter, Guardian committed that no remuneration
(other than disbursement) will be charged for its appointment, taking
up the role of administrator or performing its role. Thus, no
additional remuneration will be charged to the owners of the Estate.
27. Thus viewed, I am persuaded that Guardian is fit and proper to be
appointed as the administrator for the Estate limited to the Specified
Duty. Ms Chan confirmed that a period of three months will be
appropriate for making all necessary arrangements for performing the
Specified Duty.
DISPOSITION
28. Taking matters in the round, I am satisfied that the Applicant has
successfully proved his case. It is necessary to appoint an
administrator to perform the Specified Duty as sought by the Applicant
and Guardian is fit and proper to be appointed for such limited
purpose.
ORDER
29. Having considered all the evidence before me and the submission of the
Applicant, I make an Order that:
1) the incumbent management committee of the Respondent be
dissolved;
2) Guardian Property Management Limited be appointed under Section
31 of the Building Management Ordinance (Cap. 344) as an
administrator of Greenville Gardens of Shiu Fai Terrace at no
remuneration solely for the limited purpose of convening and
conducting a general meeting of owners for election of new
members to form the management committee for the Respondent;
3) Guardian Property Management Limited shall hold office for a
term of 3 months from the date hereof or until the new members
for the management committee of the Respondent are elected,
whichever is the earlier;
4) the order made herein be served in the following manners:
a. by displaying a sealed copy of the Order made herein at the
notice board and the main entrance of each block of the
Estate within 7 days from the date hereof;
b. sending a sealed copy of the order made herein to the
Respondent at its registered office;
5) There be no order as to costs of these proceedings including all
costs reserved and this hearing.
30. On a final note, it is noteworthy that not only does Guardian charge
no remuneration for its appointment as an administrator, but the
Applicant also seeks no order as to costs. In other words, the
Applicant is to bear his own costs of the whole proceedings. Coupled
with his efforts to enlist Guardian’s assistance and his outreach to
other owners to support the present application, his present
application is made manifestly out of a commitment to contribute to
the Estate and guided by the best interests of the Estate.
31. I thank Ms Chan for her assistance.
|Michelle LAM |
|Presiding Officer |
|Lands Tribunal |
Ms Angel Chan, Huen & Partners, solicitor for the Applicant
The Respondent was not represented and did not appear
-----------------------
[1] See The Minutes of the Extraordinary General Meeting of the Estate on
17 December 2024
[2] The owner who has not signed the letter was said to be out of Hong Kong
for the moment and therefore was unable to sign the joint letter.
-----------------------
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
-----------------------
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V