Case Details

Citation

CENTURY WIDE DEVELOPMENT LTD v. LAI YEE WAH AND OTHERS, LDCS 11000/2016

Case Number

LDCS 11000/2016

Registry reference: LDCS11000M/2016

Court

Lands Tribunal

(LT)

Decision Date

8 November 2019

Parties

Applicant(s):

CENTURY WIDE DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (廣源發展有限公司)

Respondent(s):

LOONG HUBERT HO FUNG (龍浩鋒) and LOONG HON BIU (龍漢標) 1st Respondents (Discontinued) MAIN SEA DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (萬海發展有限公司), MAIN SEA DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (萬海發展有限公司), KNOW BEST LIMITED, LAM CHAU HAN (林秋嫻), the Administratrix of the Estate of NG SAI YING (伍世楹), the Administrator of the Estate of LUI KWAN HEUNG (雷群香) also known as NG LUI KWAN HEUNG (伍雷群香), LAI YEE WAH (黎綺華) and FONG KIN YIP (方建業), FONG YING (方瑩), LI WAH CHEONG (李華昌), LI HON CHEONG (李漢昌), LI KIN CHEONG (李建昌), LI KWOK CHEONG (李國昌) and LI CHUN CHEONG (李振昌), THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY INCORPORATED, WONG HOLLY (黃可妮), THE PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF CHUNG CHUN CHU (鍾珍珠), DECEASED, LEE PAK SING (李栢盛), TSANG WOO KAY (曾活琦), HO WOON YIN (何煥然), LAU SIU HING (劉兆興), LOUIE HONG SUE GAY (雷湯瑞桂) and MING LEONG LOUIE (雷明諒)

Judges

Mr Alex Ng
Member of the Lands Tribunal

CENTURY WIDE DEVELOPMENT LTD v. LAI YEE WAH AND OTHERS

Lands Tribunal8 November 2019

Judges:Mr Alex NgMember of the Lands Tribunal

LDCS11000M/2016 CENTURY WIDE DEVELOPMENT LTD v. LAI YEE WAH AND OTHERS

LDCS 11000/2016

[2019] HKLdT 65

IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

LAND COMPULSORY SALE MAIN APPLICATION NO 11000 OF 2016

________________________

BETWEEN

	CENTURY WIDE DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (廣源發展有限公司)	Applicant
	and
	LOONG HUBERT HO FUNG (龍浩鋒) and LOONG HON BIU (龍漢標)	1^st Respondents (Discontinued)
	MAIN SEA DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (萬海發展有限公司)	2^nd Respondent (Discontinued)
	HO CHEUK NAM (何灼南) and CHU WAI CHUN (朱慧珍)	3^rd Respondents (Discontinued)
	HO CHEUK NAM (何灼南) and CHU WAI CHUN (朱慧珍)	3^rd Respondents (Discontinued)
	KNOW BEST LIMITED	4^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	LAM CHAU HAN (林秋嫻), the Administratrix of the Estate of NG SAI YING (伍世楹), the Administrator of the Estate of LUI KWAN HEUNG (雷群香) also known as NG LUI KWAN HEUNG (伍雷群香)	5^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	LAI YEE WAH (黎綺華) and FONG KIN YIP (方建業)	6^th Respondent
	FONG YING (方瑩)	7^th Respondent
	LI WAH CHEONG (李華昌), LI HON CHEONG (李漢昌), LI KIN CHEONG (李建昌), LI KWOK CHEONG (李國昌) and LI CHUN CHEONG (李振昌)	8^th Respondent
	THE FINANCIAL SECRETARY INCORPORATED	9^th Respondent
	WONG HOLLY (黃可妮)	10^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	THE PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF CHUNG CHUN CHU (鍾珍珠), DECEASED	11^th Respondent
	LEE PAK SING (李栢盛)	12^th Respondent
	TSANG WOO KAY (曾活琦)	13^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	HO WOON YIN (何煥然)	14^th Respondent (Discontinued)
	LAU SIU HING (劉兆興)	15^th Respondent
	LOUIE HONG SUE GAY (雷湯瑞桂) and MING LEONG LOUIE (雷明諒)	16^th Respondent

________________________

Before:

Mr Alex Ng, Member of the Lands Tribunal

Date of Judgment:	8 November 2019
Date of Corrigendum:	28 November 2019

________________________

C O R R I G E N D U M

________________________

Please note the following corrigendum in the Judgment dated 8 November 2019: -

1. Paragraph 38 should read as follows: -

The EUVs of all units in the Building as at the relevant date of valuation, i.e. 3 November 2016, and adopted by this tribunal are appended below: -

Address	Floor	Unit	EUV
Nos 39-41 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	-	$44,610,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	-	$18,790,000
No 45 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	Portion 1	$12,640,000
No 45 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	Portion 2	$7,200,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	Portion A	$6,760,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	Portion B	$13,010,000
No 49 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	-	$18,790,000
Nos 51-53 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	Shop A	$8,280,000
Nos 51-53 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	Shop B	$35,890,000
No 2 Pok Man St	G	-	$16,690,000
No 1 Ka Shin St	G	Flat A	$9,810,000
No 1 Ka Shin St	G	Portion B	$9,760,000
No 43A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	-	$7,630,000
No 45A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	-	$7,780,000
No 47A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	-	$7,780,000
No 49A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	G	-	$7,630,000
No 39 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$5,900,000
No 41 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$4,800,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$5,360,000
No 45 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$5,080,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$5,240,000
No 49 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$5,360,000
No 51 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$4,800,000
No 53 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$6,270,000
No 2 Pok Man St	1	-	$3,970,000
No 43A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$3,830,000
No 45A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$3,920,000
No 47A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$3,800,000
No 49A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	1	-	$3,720,000
No 1 Ka Shin St	1	-	$4,100,000
No 39 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$5,750,000
No 41 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$4,350,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$4,560,000
No 45 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$4,600,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$4,600,000
No 49 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$4,710,000
No 51 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$4,210,000
No 53 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$5,750,000
No 2 Pok Man St	2	-	$4,000,000
No 43A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$3,630,000
No 45A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$3,830,000
No 47A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$3,830,000
No 49A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	2	-	$3,750,000
No 1 Ka Shin St	2	-	$4,000,000
No 39 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$5,790,000
No 41 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$4,570,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	Portion No 1	$1,340,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	Portion No 2	$2,110,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	Portion No 3	$890,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	Portion No 4	$1,200,000
No 45 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$5,140,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$4,990,000
No 49 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$5,100,000
No 51 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$4,860,000
No 53 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$5,790,000
No 2 Pok Man St	3	-	$3,780,000
No 43A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$3,650,000
No 45A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$3,850,000
No 47A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$3,730,000
No 49A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	3	-	$3,650,000
No 1 Ka Shin St	3	-	$3,900,000
No 39 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$5,470,000
No 41 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$4,590,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$4,980,000
No 45 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$4,870,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	Flat 1	$1,810,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	Flat 2	$1,480,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	Flat 3	$1,630,000
No 49 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$4,980,000
No 51 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$4,450,000
No 53 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$5,470,000
No 2 Pok Man St	4	-	$3,690,000
No 43A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$3,560,000
No 45A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$3,640,000
No 47A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$3,530,000
No 49A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	4	-	$3,560,000
No 1 Ka Shin St	4	-	$3,690,000
No 39 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$5,070,000
No 41 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$4,120,000
No 43 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$4,610,000
No 45 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$4,360,000
No 47 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$4,360,000
No 49 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$4,320,000
No 51 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$4,120,000
No 53 Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$5,070,000
No 2 Pok Man St	5	-	$3,520,000
No 43A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$3,190,000
No 45A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$3,270,000
No 47A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$3,160,000
No 49A Tai Kok Tsui Rd	5	-	$3,090,000
No 1 Ka Shin St	5	-	$3,300,000

	(Alex Ng)
	Member
	Lands Tribunal

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Case Details

Citation

CENTURY WIDE DEVELOPMENT LTD v. LAI YEE WAH AND OTHERS, LDCS 11000/2016

Case Number

LDCS 11000/2016

Registry reference: LDCS11000M/2016

Court

Lands Tribunal

(LT)

Decision Date

8 November 2019

Parties

Applicant(s):

CENTURY WIDE DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (廣源發展有限公司)

Respondent(s):

Judges

Mr Alex Ng
Member of the Lands Tribunal