Case Details
Listing:
KARNATI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
KARNATI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
[2026] HKCFI 5906 · HCAL 1353/2023
Court of First Instance
HCAL 1353/2023
[2026] HKCFI 5906
IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST No. 1353 of 2023
BETWEEN
| |Karnati |Applicant |
| | | |
| |and | |
| | | |
| |Torture Claims Appeal Board/ |Putative |
| |Non-refoulement Claims Petition Office |Respondent |
| |and | |
| | | |
| |Director of Immigration |Putative |
| | |Interested |
| | |Party |
| | | |
| |Application for Leave to Apply for | |
| |Judicial Review | |
| |NOTIFICATION of the Judge’s decision (Ord.| |
| |53 r. 3) | |
Following:
|( |consideration of documents only; or |
| | |
|( |consideration of documents and oral submissions by the Applicant in open |
| |court; |
Order by Deputy High Court Judge (Non-refoulement Claims) Keith Lam:
The application for leave to apply for judicial review be dismissed.
Observations for the Applicant:
Introduction
1. By Form 86 filed on 4 August 2023 (“Form 86”), the Applicant seeks
leave to apply for judicial review of the decision of the Torture
Claims Appeal Board (“TCAB”) dated 14 July 2023 (“TCAB Decision”),
which affirmed the decision of the Director of Immigration (“DOI”)
dated 23 August 2022 (“DOI Decision”).
2. The Applicant requested for a hearing of this application, which was
held on 16 September 2026. When asked, she referred to her situation,
being that her mother had passed away and her house is being sold, and
that she wishes that she can stay longer in Hong Kong.
Background
3. The Applicant is a national of Indonesia. In gist, she fears that she
will be harmed or even killed by her two stepbrothers who threatened
to kill her for suggesting that she could inherit a share in their
parents’ house and making suggestions about redeveloping the house.
The Applicant’s personal background, the relevant facts and relevant
procedural history have been sufficiently set out in the TCAB
Decision, which can be viewed through a hyperlink.[1] There is no
need for me to repeat the same. Unless otherwise specified, the
abbreviations and descriptions used in the TCAB Decision are adopted
herein.
Discussion
4. The leave application operates as a filtering process and there is no
requirement or expectation to give elaborate reasons for my decision:
Re Zunariyah [2018] HKCA 14 at §23. I therefore set out below brief
reasons for my decision, which I have reached upon considering all the
materials before me.
5. In a judicial review, this court does not provide a further avenue of
appeal. While I remind myself that in non-refoulement cases, I would
adopt an enhanced standard in scrutinising the decision of the TCAB
given the seriousness of the issue at hand, this court would not usurp
the role of the TCAB, which together with the DOI are the primary
decision-makers. A finding of fact is exclusively within the realm of
the TCAB, and this court will not intervene by way of judicial review
unless there are errors of law or procedural unfairness or
irrationality in the decision of the TCAB: Nupur Mst v Director of
Immigration [2018] HKCA 524 at §14(1). There must be a reasonably
arguable case with a realistic prospect of success before leave for
judicial review will be granted: Peter Po Fun Chan v Winnie Cheung
(2007) 10 HKCFAR 676 at §§14-17.
6. An applicant is required to clearly and succinctly identify the
grounds of judicial review relied upon in the Form 86 and the
supporting affirmation: Ho Loy v Director of Environment Protection,
HCAL 21/2015 (unrep.) 22.12.2016 at §142. He or she is also under a
duty to make full and frank disclosure of material facts: Kan Hung
Cheung v The Director of Immigration [2008] HKC 323 at §§14-17.
7. The Applicant stated the following grounds of judicial review in the
supporting affirmation: -
1) “Adjudicator did not consider my claim. Adjudicator directly
dismissed. He did not even take time or did not think about my
life.” (“Ground 1”)
2) “I had some documents but all in my mother language. I submitted
all but Adjudicator did not accept because he could not
understand.” (“Ground 2”)
3) “I request him to give me some time to translate in English of my
all documents and I too took some preparation but my officer had
no time.” (“Ground 3”)
4) “Translator did not help me at all. If I did not understand he
became angry.” (“Ground 4”)
5) “Interpreter asked me to not take long time for interview as he
had another job.” (“Ground 5”)
6) “Please help me and safe my life.” (“Ground 6”)
8. I have scrutinised the TCAB Decision carefully and come to the view
that none of the above Grounds can be established or considered as
valid or effective public law grounds. I also do not find any error
of law or procedural unfairness or irrationality on the part of the
TCAB Decision.
9. Most if not all of the grounds merely consist of generic, vague and/or
unparticularised assertions without reference to any underlying facts
or matters establishing why, how and where each of those complaints
arise in relation to the TCAB Decision. General assertions without
particulars are not effective grounds and cannot assist the Applicant:
Re Haider Khalil [2021] HKCA 223 at §16.
10. Ground 1 is clearly not correct given that the TCAB Decision
considered the Applicant’s evidence about the alleged threat to her
life in detail, as discussed in §13 below.
11. Ground 2 to Ground 5 are bare assertions and are contrary to what was
recorded in the DOI Decision and the TCAB Decision and must be
rejected: -
1) Before the DOI, the Applicant had been represented by the Duty
Lawyer Service as the Notice of Decision of 23 August 2022 was
sent to the Applicant through them.
2) It would appear from the DOI Decision that, in the Applicant’s
initial application and at her interview with the Immigration
Department, she had no difficulty in providing detailed
information about her claim: see DOI Decision §6. In particular,
the DOI Decision quoted or referred to various responses from the
Applicant to the DOI’s questions at the screening interview:
§§6.6, 6.9, 6.17, 6.19, 6.21, 6.25-6.26.
3) Despite the allegation that the Applicant had some documents in
her mother language to submit to the Adjudicator which he refused
to consider, no such documents are presented in her supporting
affirmation in this application.
4) The Applicant attended the oral hearing before the TCAB without
legal representation. There was however no indication of any
difficulty in giving evidence and/or answering the questions
raised by the TCAB. As recorded in the TCAB Decision, the
Applicant was able to provide various additional information
during the oral hearing before the TCAB, and there were various
occasions at the hearing where the TCAB made inquiries of the
Applicant and the Applicant’s responses were recorded: see TCAB
Decision §§39-40.
12. Ground 6 self-evidently has no substance.
13. As can be seen from the TCAB Decision, the TCAB took into account all
the evidence available and found that on the basis of the same,
applying the correct legal principles in respect of all applicable
grounds under the Unified Screening Mechanism, the Applicant’s
allegations were insufficient to make out any of the applicable
grounds: §§32-91. It is clear that the TCAB considered the evidence
available thoroughly and in detail. In particular, the TCAB found
that:
1) The TCAB found that the Applicant’s evidence was incredible and
did not accept her claims that her stepmother had suggested that
the house would be shared amongst the 5 children, and that she was
threatened and assaulted by her two stepbrothers: TCAB Decision
§§51-55. In particular, some of the Applicant’s claims were
unsustainable and she had to retract them. For example, she
initially claimed that it was her birthmother who suggested the
land and house would be divided to the 5 siblings (including the
two stepbrothers) before she died in 2002. But that cannot be
right because her two stepbrothers could only have come into the
picture after her birthmother died and her stepmother came into
the picture – when this was pointed out, the Applicant changed her
evidence and said it was the stepmother who made that suggestion:
§53. I consider that the TCAB was entitled to come to this
conclusion.
2) The TCAB also concluded that even if the Applicant’s claims are
accepted, her claim would still fail: §57. It found that the risk
of her being harmed by her two stepbrothers if returned to
Indonesia was low, given in particular that the last contact she
had with her stepbrothers was in 2002 (whereupon she left
Indonesia to work overseas), and her last contact with her family
members was in 2018. Her stepbrothers had taken no further steps
against her during these years. The TCAB found that the threats
were just posturing and there was no real intent to kill the
Applicant. See: TCAB Decision §60. Further, the Applicant had
returned to Indonesia in 2011 and stayed at the dorm of the
recruitment agency which was only 2 hours’ drive away from her
home in Indonesia, and this suggests that the Applicant did not
consider there was serious risk of harm in returning to Indonesia:
TCAB Decision §61.
3) Further, other than a bare assertion that the two stepbrothers had
extensive social contacts, there is no evidence that they would
have the connection or ability to be able to locate the Applicant
anywhere in Indonesia other than her home village. Thus, given
her background and working experience, the Applicant could
relocate to another part of Indonesia to avoid the alleged harm by
them: TCAB Decision §§62, 72-73.
4) The TCAB also considered country of origin information, and found
that, although there is a degree of corruption in the Indonesian
police, the government have been taking steps to combat
corruption, and the Applicant could receive reasonable protection
if she seeks assistance or protection from the police. There is no
evidence that the government or police would acquiesce in the
alleged conduct of the two stepbrothers: §§67-71.
14. I have also considered the Applicant’s oral submissions. The matters
raised clearly do not amount to grounds for judicial review of the
TCAB Decision. In any case, if there are changes in the circumstances
or new information that are material to her case for non-refoulement,
the applicant may consider providing the information or new evidence
to the DOI, who is the primary decision maker, pursuant to section
37ZO(2) of the Immigration Ordinance (Cap 115). Such matters are not
relevant to the present application (Amandeep Kumar v Torture Claims
Appeal Board [2019] HKCA 1369 at §13; Poinem v Torture Claims Appeal
Board [2020] HKCA 911 at §15).
Conclusion
15. Therefore, I do not find any error of law or procedural unfairness or
irrationality on the part of the TCAB Decision. I conclude that the
Applicant’s intended challenge against the TCAB Decision is not
reasonably arguable, and accordingly the application for leave to
apply for judicial review is dismissed.
Dated the 2nd day of November 2026
| |(Joyce Ooi) |
| |for Registrar, High |
| |Court |
Where leave to apply has been granted, Applicants and their legal advisers
are reminded of their obligation to reconsider the merits of their
application in the light of the Respondent’s evidence
|Notes for the | | |
|Applicant: | | |
| | | |
|If leave has been | | |
|granted, the Applicant | | |
|or the Applicant’s | | |
|solicitors must: | | |
|a) serve on the |Sent to the |Sent to the Putative |
|respondent and such |Applicant |Respondent / the |
|interested parties as |on 2/11/2026 |Putative Respondent’s |
|may be directed by the | |solicitors / such |
|Court the order |Karnati |Putative Interested |
|granting leave and any | |Parties as may be |
|directions given within|Applicant’s ref. no:|directed by the Court / |
|14 days after the leave|Nil. |the Putative Interested |
|was granted (Order 53, | |Parties’ solicitors on |
|rule 4A); | |2/11/2026 |
| | | |
|b) issue the | |Torture Claims Appeal |
|originating summons | |Board/Non-refoulement |
|within 14 days after | |Claims Petition Office |
|the grant of leave and | |Putative Respondent’s |
|serve it in accordance | |ref. no.: USM 20904 |
|with Order 53, rule 5; | | |
|and | |Director of Immigration |
| | |Putative Interested |
|c) supply to every | |Party’s ref. no.: QA T/C|
|other party copies of | |771/22 (formerly RBCZ |
|every affidavit which | |5000637/22) |
|the Applicant proposes | | |
|to use at the hearing, | |Department of Justice, |
|including the affidavit| |Senior Assistant Law |
|in support of the | |Officer |
|application for leave | |(Civil Law) |
|(Order 53, rule 6(5)). | |(Civil Litigation Unit |
| | |2) |
Form CALL-1
-----------------------
[1]https://legalref.judiciary.hk/doc/judg/html/vetted/other/en/2023/HCAL0013
53_2023_files/the_Board's_Decision.pdf