Case Details
Citation
LAI PUI AND ANOTHER v. CHINA MOTOR BUS CO LTD AND ANOTHER, HCA 186/1977
Case Number
HCA 186/1977
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Decision Date
11 November 1977
Parties
Respondent(s):

CHEUNG MAN YIP the co-administrator of the estate of CHAN SHUEN YEE, deceased Plaintiffs and CHINA MOTOR BUS COMPANY LIMITED, CHINA MOTOR BUS COMPANY LIMITED, LO TAT MING

For Applicant(s):

Christopher Young instructed by Messrs. Haldane & Co.

For Respondent(s):

will turn next to the question of credibility. Both Mr. Lai and his daughter gave evidence and denied, inter alia, having given a part of their statements to the police. It was also denied that none of their statements was read back to them; nor were they allowed the opportunity to go through the same. Counsel; sought to make capital of certain discrepancies between the recorded statements and the viva voce evidence of the plaintiff and his daughter. Having read the statements given by Mr. Lai and his daughter, it may very well be that the discrepancies cannot be said to be of vital importance, but I should hasten to add that there seems to be ample justification for counsel; have had opportunities of observing the demeanour of Mr. Lai and his daughter, Miss Lai, the police officers and the other witnesses. In the end, suffice it for me to say that in so far as the evidence of Mr. Lai and Miss Lai conflicts with the evidence of and

LAI PUI AND ANOTHER v. CHINA MOTOR BUS CO LTD AND ANOTHER

HCA 186/1977

Court of First Instance11 November 1977

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations