Case Details
Citation
SZE CHIU AND ANOTHER v. WONG WANG-YEE AND ANOTHER, CACV 25/1978
Case Number
CACV 25/1978
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
5 February 1979
Parties
Applicant(s):

SZE Chiu, SZE King-yuen

Respondent(s):

WONG Wang-yee, WONG Moon-yee

For Applicant(s):

respect of the provisions of section 53 which inhibits the Court from making an order for possession unless it is satisfied that (inter alia) "any rent lawfully due from the tenant or sub-tenant has not been paid." The rent reserved under the Agreement for the four and a half year term was $10 per month and it is common ground that, as pleaded in the Statement of Claim, it has never been paid. Mr. Bernacchi; B. Bernacchi, Q.C. & H.L. Wong (K.M. Lai & Li)

For Respondent(s):

per month is not a pecuniary rent or that if it is, the maxim de minimis non curat lex should apply to it and that Part II of the Landlord and Tenant (Consolidation) Ordinance (in which is contained section 52(1)) applies only to tenancies the subject of pecuniary rentals so that the 1st Defendant is not, in any event, entitled to the protection of that sub-section. Mr. Cheung; Oswald Cheung, Q.C. & Miss H.C. Wong (H.H.Lau & Co.); Miss H.C. Wong (H.H. Lau & Co.)

SZE CHIU AND ANOTHER v. WONG WANG-YEE AND ANOTHER

CACV 25/1978

Court of Appeal5 February 1979

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations