Case Details
Citation
TSANG YAU CHOO AND ANOTHER v. THE QUEEN, CACC 911/1974
Case Number
CACC 911/1974
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
27 March 1975
Parties
Respondent(s):

THE QUEEN

For Applicant(s):

The charge therefore alleged that the Appellants had conspired to offer some benefit to Mr. Heslop for a corrupt (although unspecified) purpose. The essential ingredients of the charge were all there, but there was a lack of particularity which might embarrass the defence. That lack might well have justified a request for particulars but it was not a ground for quashing the charge. It may have been unfortunate

For Respondent(s):

police notebook should not have been admitted in evidence, Here we are greatly hampered by the inadequacy of the record. Originally the notebook was used by Mr. Heslop to refresh his memory and it was rightly not made an exhibit. Later in Mr. Heslop's examination-in-chide Mr. Hampton objected to the admission of the notebook as evidence of the facts recorded therein, an objection which was well taken if counsel; was admitted during the cross-examination of Mr. Heslop, but there is nothing in the record indicating when the notebook was marked or that any formal request for its admission was ever made. The fact that its number bore the prefix "P." is some evidence that the exhibit was admitted at the request of the prosecution, but in all the circumstances that evidence is of little weight. Counsel; sought to assert that it was never his intention to have the notebook admitted and that it was in truth the Defendants' document, while we were told that the solicitor

TSANG YAU CHOO AND ANOTHER v. THE QUEEN

CACC 911/1974

Court of Appeal27 March 1975

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations